Editor’s Note: Paris tragedy raises questions on journalistic morality

By Taylor St. Germain
Editor-in-Chief

Unfortunately, in recent weeks, we have all heard of the tragic events that occurred in Paris at the Charlie Hebdo offices. Acts of terror, such as the most recent shooting, are in no way excusable, and today, the world is still mourning the loss of 12 innocent journalists.

However, this tragedy also gives us the opportunity to reflect on the topic of freedom of speech in today’s society. Journalism is ever-changing; day-by-day, societal norms are being challenged, and new limits are being pushed. Charlie Hebdo, a satirical magazine in Paris, certainly pushed those limits.

But, I have recently asked myself, at what point do we place a limit on free speech? At what point does our respect for human culture, whether it be religion or tradition, outweigh our legal rights?

I have recently struggled with these questions as I have reflected on the Charlie Hebdo tragedy. I have yet to come to any final conclusions. And truthfully, I don’t believe there is one sole answer to my question.

Way back in freshman beginning journalism, we were taught to follow four rules when it comes to freedom of speech: what we publish cannot be libelous, slanderous, obscene, or pornographic. These principles are expected, especially within a high school newspaper.

However, must we also have respect for the subjects we discuss? I know, in my time on La Vista, we have certainly published some questionable words, whether purposely or completely by accident. But to what extent can we offend and push the boundaries of what is appropriate? I think that we must be careful.

However, I don’t think drawing offense is the issue at hand. Before we publish, we must think to ourselves whether we believe the words or images we wish to print are morally correct. As a journalist, I must use my own, personal moral compass to decide the difference between right and wrong.

And, I know in the future, when we sit down to compile “Pun InTENded” or our editorial pages, I will most certainly be reminded of Charlie Hebdo and I will think about the profound questions that the magazine has risen in the world of journalism.